Keith-Carradine Movie Reviews


Action, supense

Gambling, I don't think so! Its great!

Gambling, I don't think so! Its great!

Review of JUDGMENT

A Depression-era tragic romance that's quintessential Altman

"Honour is, for him, an appetite."Harvey Keitel as the murderous Feraud is very believable. His body language smacks of pure hatred and instinct to kill whenever he hears D'Hubert's name mentioned. Keith Carradine as D'Hubert is a little weak and wooden--not nearly as believable as Keitel. Feraud and D'Hubert are complete opposites. Feraud is very much the brutish man-of-action--whereas D'Hubert is made of gentler stuff. Feraud considers D'Hubert to be nothing better than "a general's poodle," and D'Hubert thinks Feraud is insane.
Visually, this film is magnificent, and it's worth watching just for the costumes and sets alone. The dueling scenes were superbly created--with each man facing his enemy--usually at dawn. The light coming through the trees, the swirling mists--this created the perfect atmosphere. The scene at the very end of the film focused on the sky--dark grey clouds--with just a little light. It was the most beautiful scene in the entire film. The film is based on the Joseph Conrad short story, "The Duel"--displacedhuman
Only Barry Lyndon Compares VisuallyBased on a story by Joseph Conrad, chosen because the rights had lapsed, the film concerns two French hussar officers, one of whom, played with republican fervor by Harvey Keitel, is quick to anger and to duel. His nemesis is the aristocratic officer played by Robert Carradine, who doesn't understand why Keitel hates him so much. The film follows their careers in the Napoleonic wars over the course of fifteen years, from the early triumphs of l'Emporer in Lubeck, to the disaster of Russia, and the return of the Bourbon's. Despite their long-standing animosity, Carradine even saves Keitel from the guillotine, for which he his repayed with disdain and aggression.
This story is episodic, and there are many loose ends, but who cares? This is one of the most astonishing films ever made in its meticulousness, it's bravery (not cow-towing to hi-key filmic conventions), it's invention (a budget of only $900,000 dollars?!) and in the totally successful vision the filmmakers put up on the screen. Films costing 10 times as much or more are not so riviting as this film.
Scott did have to compromise; he wished for Michael York and Oliver Reed, but the financiers wanted American actors. Even though Carradine is occasionally weak, Keitel is intense throughout.
The Duellist is one of my favorite films. The DVD transfer is immaculate and the special features give us interviews with Ridley Scott, and the film's composers notes on his musical choices.
A gorgeous movie!The story revolves around a series of duels between two French army officers, D'hubert (Carradine) and Feraud (Keitel). Feraud is the heavy of the piece, having started the duels for no reason whatsoever. But D'hubert's own warped sense of honor won't allow him to refuse the challenges.
Neither of the leads was Scott's first choice; the two actors he wanted were refused by the studio funding the project. If he wanted the money, he had to choose from a list of four actors the studio gave him. And he wanted the money. So literally every other actor in the film is better, and fits in the film better, than the two leads. Doesn't matter. This is a stunningly beautiful film. Every scene is so gorgeous it is like a painting. It is all about the scenery and the costumes. Every military history buff should own a copy of this DVD just for the costumes alone.
The DVD itself is gorgeous, with vivid colors, and it is crammed with extras including a director's commentary with Ridley Scott. Get it.

The barely functional unit of city boys and macho rednecks invades the environs of the local Cajun trappers and poachers, "borrowing" the locals' boats and sending bursts of blank rounds over their heads in a show of contempt. Before they know it the dysfunctional strangers in a strange land are on the losing end of a guerrilla war. The swamp rats kill their commanding officer (Peter Coyote) and terrorize the bickering bunch as they flee blindly through the jungle without a map, a compass, or a leader to speak of.
Hill directs with a clean simplicity, creating tension as much from the primal landscape and the Cajuns' unsettling reign of terror as from the dynamics of a platoon of battle virgins tearing itself apart from rage and fear. Ry Cooder's eerie and haunting score and the primal, claustrophobic landscape only intensifies the paranoia as the city boys splinter with infighting (sparked by a bullying Fred Ward), blunder through booby traps and ambushes, and finally turn just as savage as their pursuers in their drive to survive. --Sean Axmaker

Weekend warriors stalked by Cajun huntersWalter Hill's taunt direction and script (based on Michael Kane's original script and rewritten with long time collaborator David Giler)bring this backwoods Apocalypse Now to life. While it integrates elements of Delieverence, Apocalypse Now and a number of 50's b-movie aspects into its clever script, Southern Comfort is far from derivative due to the direction, photography and strong acting.
Powers Boothe and Fred Ward (in an early major role)virtually steal the movie from star Keith Carradine. Boothe a surpremely talented underused performer, shines in his role as Hardin the recent Texas transplant. The cast of character actors features strong performances from Peter Coyote (in a pre-E.T. performance) and Brion James (Blade Runner)as well. The interaction of these bickering weekend warriors makes the picture come to life. The setting makes this all the more believable as many males of adult age chose the National Guard to the alternative of serving in Vietnam (the film is set in 1973).
The transfer is very good. There's not a lot of analot artifacts and there's little of the compression problems that one has come to expect from budget priced DVDs. While the film is given a bare bones (it's a companion to MGM's Midnite Movie series)presentation with only foreign language tracks, subtitles and the original trailer, it is presented in its original aspect ratio. The sound is quite good as well and is true to its original stereo soundtrack.
I'd highly recommend this underrated and forgotten thriller.
Suspense and tension galore in this swamp thrillerThe movie is essentially about a bunch of wanna-be National Guards sent out on a routine weekend mission in the swamps of Louisiana, only to find themselves at war with some mean locals. When water appears where land should be, the troop has no choice but to borrow some unattended boats belonging to some Cajun locals. Of course, things go awry when the troop member, plagued with idiocy, shoots a round of blanks at the locals for sheer fun. Things heat up real fast as the wanna-be guards begin the fight for survival in an unknown territory with only blanks. Some scenes get you so riled up, you'll be at the edge of your seat shouting "what the . . . !" Unfortunately, the captain and another member sometimes come across as poor actors, but depending on how you see it, that could be explained as an approach to portray realistic men who just don't know what the heck they're doing. Afterall, from the beginning, the Sergeant pleads with them to act like real soldiers for once in their life.
The film seems to work best as a "survival of the fittest" story instead of a macho-type, action-packed war movie. The eerie swamp certainly contributes to many nerve-racking moments. Slightly puzzling ending, but still a relatively good film. Certainly above standard.
An underrated gem
The barely functional unit of city boys and macho rednecks invades the environs of the local Cajun trappers and poachers, "borrowing" the locals' boats and sending bursts of blank rounds over their heads in a show of contempt. Before they know it the dysfunctional strangers in a strange land are on the losing end of a guerrilla war. The swamp rats kill their commanding officer (Peter Coyote) and terrorize the bickering bunch as they flee blindly through the jungle without a map, a compass, or a leader to speak of.
Hill directs with a clean simplicity, creating tension as much from the primal landscape and the Cajuns' unsettling reign of terror as from the dynamics of a platoon of battle virgins tearing itself apart from rage and fear. Ry Cooder's eerie and haunting score and the primal, claustrophobic landscape only intensifies the paranoia as the city boys splinter with infighting (sparked by a bullying Fred Ward), blunder through booby traps and ambushes, and finally turn just as savage as their pursuers in their drive to survive. --Sean Axmaker

Weekend warriors stalked by Cajun huntersWalter Hill's taunt direction and script (based on Michael Kane's original script and rewritten with long time collaborator David Giler)bring this backwoods Apocalypse Now to life. While it integrates elements of Delieverence, Apocalypse Now and a number of 50's b-movie aspects into its clever script, Southern Comfort is far from derivative due to the direction, photography and strong acting.
Powers Boothe and Fred Ward (in an early major role)virtually steal the movie from star Keith Carradine. Boothe a surpremely talented underused performer, shines in his role as Hardin the recent Texas transplant. The cast of character actors features strong performances from Peter Coyote (in a pre-E.T. performance) and Brion James (Blade Runner)as well. The interaction of these bickering weekend warriors makes the picture come to life. The setting makes this all the more believable as many males of adult age chose the National Guard to the alternative of serving in Vietnam (the film is set in 1973).
The transfer is very good. There's not a lot of analot artifacts and there's little of the compression problems that one has come to expect from budget priced DVDs. While the film is given a bare bones (it's a companion to MGM's Midnite Movie series)presentation with only foreign language tracks, subtitles and the original trailer, it is presented in its original aspect ratio. The sound is quite good as well and is true to its original stereo soundtrack.
I'd highly recommend this underrated and forgotten thriller.
Suspense and tension galore in this swamp thrillerThe movie is essentially about a bunch of wanna-be National Guards sent out on a routine weekend mission in the swamps of Louisiana, only to find themselves at war with some mean locals. When water appears where land should be, the troop has no choice but to borrow some unattended boats belonging to some Cajun locals. Of course, things go awry when the troop member, plagued with idiocy, shoots a round of blanks at the locals for sheer fun. Things heat up real fast as the wanna-be guards begin the fight for survival in an unknown territory with only blanks. Some scenes get you so riled up, you'll be at the edge of your seat shouting "what the . . . !" Unfortunately, the captain and another member sometimes come across as poor actors, but depending on how you see it, that could be explained as an approach to portray realistic men who just don't know what the heck they're doing. Afterall, from the beginning, the Sergeant pleads with them to act like real soldiers for once in their life.
The film seems to work best as a "survival of the fittest" story instead of a macho-type, action-packed war movie. The eerie swamp certainly contributes to many nerve-racking moments. Slightly puzzling ending, but still a relatively good film. Certainly above standard.
An underrated gem

Not Much Plot, but Strong Documentary Feel
SublimeAs others have said, this film explores the dark, realist side of the American West. However, unlike other anti-Westerns of the era like The Wild Bunch, it does so in a hauntingly beautiful, even lyrical (albeit melancholic) way, augmented by Leonard Cohen's perfectly matched songs and the atmospheric cinematography.
There are the usual Western archetypes and themes - the gunslinger, the [prostitute], the church (symbolizing redemption and civilization), etc. - but Altman turns them upside-down. The would-be hero is an insecure bumbler who lets the whore get under his skin and dies, unceremoniously, in a snowbank. There is no honor among the thieves - they shoot people for no particular reason. The church burns. And, unlike most Westerns, the film is set not in the desert, but in the foggy Pacific Northwest, adding to the murky, morally ambiguous atmosphere, which is further enhanced by the occasionally inaudible dialogue.
This understated film has none of the overwrought archness of Altman's later work, so those who have been put off by same (as I have) need not worry - these are not merely clever celebrity cameos, but characters who live and breathe and make us care about what happens to them. The film is sombre but has many naturally comic moments (thanks to Beatty's usual bumbling loverboy persona) and is never merely studied or self-important. Similarly, for those who might be skeptical, Cohen's music is his earliest, most affecting, and least pompous.
I have a very sensitive BS meter and it never buzzes during this remarkably beautiful and affecting movie. For those who really care about film, I can't recommend it highly enough.
A True Film Classic

Not Much Plot, but Strong Documentary Feel
SublimeAs others have said, this film explores the dark, realist side of the American West. However, unlike other anti-Westerns of the era like The Wild Bunch, it does so in a hauntingly beautiful, even lyrical (albeit melancholic) way, augmented by Leonard Cohen's perfectly matched songs and the atmospheric cinematography.
There are the usual Western archetypes and themes - the gunslinger, the [prostitute], the church (symbolizing redemption and civilization), etc. - but Altman turns them upside-down. The would-be hero is an insecure bumbler who lets the whore get under his skin and dies, unceremoniously, in a snowbank. There is no honor among the thieves - they shoot people for no particular reason. The church burns. And, unlike most Westerns, the film is set not in the desert, but in the foggy Pacific Northwest, adding to the murky, morally ambiguous atmosphere, which is further enhanced by the occasionally inaudible dialogue.
This understated film has none of the overwrought archness of Altman's later work, so those who have been put off by same (as I have) need not worry - these are not merely clever celebrity cameos, but characters who live and breathe and make us care about what happens to them. The film is sombre but has many naturally comic moments (thanks to Beatty's usual bumbling loverboy persona) and is never merely studied or self-important. Similarly, for those who might be skeptical, Cohen's music is his earliest, most affecting, and least pompous.
I have a very sensitive BS meter and it never buzzes during this remarkably beautiful and affecting movie. For those who really care about film, I can't recommend it highly enough.
A True Film Classic